How can you support students as they practice engaging in argument from evidence?
Argumentation – or engaging in argument from evidence – which we’ve been focusing the last several posts on – is a challenging skill that is often misunderstood. It can take many forms – from classroom talk to elaborate essays. In addition to providing students the opportunity to engage in argument from evidence, we can also provide supports to help students master this skill.
Argumentation In Writing
For one, you can help students identify elements of argumentation in scientific writing. Students can highlight claims, pieces of evidence, and the reasoning to support that evidence in scientific texts — current event articles or resources taken from scientific journals can be used for this task. There are many current events texts adapted to middle and high school reading levels available on the web, but you can also pull abstracts from scientific journals for students who read at higher levels. Seeing examples can be a powerful way for students to develop their understanding of each component.
Card sorts are another strategy I love to use with students as they develop their understanding of engaging in argument from evidence and the CER format. There are a number of variations to this approach, but essentially I provide students with two claims, several pieces of evidence, and several pieces of reasoning that connect the evidence to the claims. Students are first tasked with sorting the evidence from the reasoning and then matching the reasoning to the evidence and reasoning it supports. To increase the difficulty of the task, you can add pieces of evidence and reasoning that are not relevant or do not support the claim.
While these scaffolds are not a substitute for engaging students in developing their own arguments, they can support students understanding of the individual components and how they are connected. I recommend always trying your activities to the content you are studying, so the claims, evidence, and reasoning you are presenting students in your activities should absolutely support the disciplinary core ideas students are developing at the time.
Argumentation In Discussion
When it comes to discussions, providing students with sentence stems or starters can encourage better discussion – as students are more likely to truly listen, respond, and add to others’ ideas and offer polite feedback and critiques.
Additionally, while the skills relevant to engaging in argument (forming claims, evaluating evidence, providing and receiving feedback) may be happening throughout a learning experience, keeping it all together can be a challenge — both for students and for teachers. Documenting the process can help teachers understand the evolution of student ideas AND help students engage in better reflection and analysis.
Briefly, the process begins by students investigating a question and documenting their observations. These observations will become their data and evidence. During the observation process, students will naturally make connections to prior knowledge to create basic, informal claims — “I think it’s a…” “I think it did this because…”
In the second phase, students identify several claims (or are provided by the teacher with several possible claims) and identify which evidence supports each. This lends itself not only to identifying what claims are best supported but also what evidence could be considered “strong” – versus weak or even disconfirming.
In the third phase, students choose their claim and discuss how the combination of strong, weak, and disconfirming evidence supports their idea. Resources are structured to encourage students to go beyond simply listing the evidence but rather including that evaluation component in their reasoning.
Are you implementing the NGSS? Are you in desperate need of support?
I have your solution. The Science Teacher Tribe Course + Community. Through our professional development program, let us walk you through creating those cohesive units that tie your standards together, assessments that evaluate students on all three dimensions, and carefully crafted instruction that fosters student discovery of the content. End the course with a completely self-designed NGSS-aligned unit while earning a certificate of completion from iExploreScience!
If you’re not ready to enroll in our full professional development program, check out the free mini-course – Intro To The NGSS – to get a handle on the basics. Discover what the NGSS REALLY looks like in the classroom – from changes to your content and instruction all the way down to your assessments.
Science Teacher Tribe: Convenient and Comprehensive NGSS Professional Development
If you are anything like me, transitioning to the NGSS can be totally overwhelming. Teaching is hard as it is – you’re busy keeping up with the “normal” lessons day to day and week to week, plus grading, meetings, IEPs, behavior management, so on and so forth. I get it. Who has the time or energy to figure out all that goes into these new standards and their impact on your curriculum, let alone what it means for your teaching!
Well, I’m happy to say there IS an easier way. You don’t HAVE to muddle through everything, and you definitely don’t have to do it alone!
Imagine feeling confident that the curriculum you designed is actually aligned to the standards, that your units incorporate the three dimensions and engage your students in Science and Engineering Practices that matter. Imagine classes full of students who take ownership of their learning, who thrive on “figuring it out” and “puzzling through it” and come to learn the content through discovery. Imagine days where you DON’T have to stand in front of the class, battling for their attention, delivering boring lectures and notes, printing worksheet after worksheet, and wasting tons of time on review and reteaching — only to have your students fail to perform anyway. Imagine learning that sticks, and engaging activities (that you may already be doing!) but that lead to true understanding. It’s not magic, and it doesn’t necessarily come easy, but it IS possible.
Learn more at the Science Teacher Tribe Course and Community.